Serious asbestos management failings at Oxford University, documents reveal
The University of Oxford was ordered to release documents on its asbestos management, which showed the university was in breach of regulations designed to protect people from potentially fatal asbestos exposure.

Internal documents show that the University of Oxford was in breach of regulations designed to prevent workers and students from contracting asbestos-related diseases. The university withheld these documents for nearly a year, until the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) issued an order to release the documents to Confront.
These documents, authored in 2019 and 2020, show that dozens of university buildings containing asbestos were, for years, not properly surveyed. The university was told by an auditor of their asbestos management that this created a greater risk of people contracting potentially fatal asbestos-related diseases.
When asked, the university – which has paid out £850,000 in compensation for victims of asbestos exposure – failed to confirm that it is fully compliant with these asbestos regulations today.
Not complying with the regulations
After the UK fully banned asbestos in 1999, the UK introduced the Control of Asbestos Regulations in 2004 to manage the risk from the millions of tons of asbestos still in its buildings.
The Health & Safety Executive (HSE) is responsible for overseeing asbestos management across non-domestic buildings in the UK. The HSE states that, “people who work in older buildings could still be exposed to asbestos fibres today if asbestos is not managed effectively, and is damaged or disturbed”. The World Health Organisation says there is no safe level of exposure to asbestos, which kills over 5,000 people a year in the UK.
To better understand how this asbestos risk is being managed, Confront requested information from over 40 universities, including Oxford University. Our initial investigation found significant issues at a number of universities, and that millions of pounds had been paid out to people who had contracted potentially fatal asbestos diseases.
We now know that Oxford University, the top university in the world according to the Times Higher Education World University Rankings 2025, was in breach of these asbestos regulations, according to audit documents seen by Confront.
These audits followed shortly after the university ‘discovered’ asbestos in the Tinbergen Building on South Parks Road, leading to the building’s sudden closure and eventual demolition. An asbestos management audit was then conducted by PWC in 2019.
It found that, despite regulations for the university to manage this asbestos being introduced in 2004, the university’s asbestos management was “still in its infancy”.
Out of the estimated 235 university buildings with asbestos-containing materials, just four buildings had developed and implemented sufficient asbestos management plans. This meant that “University staff, students, contractors and visitors are at increased risk of exposure to asbestos”.
The audit noted that information regarding the location, type and condition of asbestos-containing materials was “not complete, consistent nor up-to-date.”
In January, we published that Oxford University has 4,609 asbestos-containing materials across its buildings. Of these, 24 were classified as “high-risk”, 2,135 classified as “medium-risk,” 1,644 as “low-risk”, and 806 as “unclassified”.
Confusion about the university’s responsibilities to manage asbestos was widespread. The legally appointed person (the duty holder) within the university for complying with the regulations was, at one point early on in their role, seemingly unaware of their responsibilities. The audit found, “[They] may not have been sufficiently informed about her responsibilities and duties as the appointed duty holder, nor about the current regulatory compliance status in regards to the Control of Asbestos Regulations 2012.”
This confusion also filtered down into training, with some staff who had responsibilities for managing asbestos having received no such training during their employment at the university.
No response on compliance today
The second audit noted improvements, though there was still substantial work to be done for Oxford University to fully comply with the Control of Asbestos Regulations. The university was due to have had 72 asbestos-management plans completed by June 2020, but only 23 were issued. The university still had a large number of older buildings containing asbestos without asbestos management surveys, with only 97 out of 160 of the highest-risk buildings being fully surveyed.
Goals were outlined to make the university compliant and to ensure better understanding across departments of their obligations to manage their asbestos. There has not been a third audit to see if the university met all of the goals that were outlined in 2020.
Confront asked Oxford University whether it was currently compliant with the Control of Asbestos Regulations. It declined to respond to this question.
We also asked for an explanation as to why, for at least 16 years, the university failed to comply with the regulations. No explanation was provided. A university spokesperson said, “Oxford University has a large, diverse estate with buildings of a wide range of ages. As a consequence, asbestos-containing materials are present in some of these. We are confident that the systems and processes in place provide suitable protection against the risk of asbestos exposure for everyone who uses our buildings.”
Asbestos diseases
It usually takes decades after exposure for asbestos diseases to develop. The most notorious asbestos disease is mesothelioma, a terminal cancer with no known cure.
Professor Dennis Shaw worked at Oxford University in various roles between 1957 and 1991. Shaw, who was keeper of the scientific books in the Radcliffe Science Library before retirement, was diagnosed with the asbestos cancer mesothelioma in December 2016. He died in July 2017, aged 93.
Before his death, Shaw left a statement which was read out at his inquest. He identified some time he spent supervising the extension of the Bodleian library at Oxford University in the 1970s as one of the potential sites where he could have been exposed to asbestos, along with the construction of synchrotron facilities in Geneva. The coroner reported the death as being from industrial disease. The exact sources of the asbestos exposure that caused Shaw’s mesothelioma are not known.
His daughter Deborah Shaw was reported by Oxford Mail in October 2017 during the inquest as saying, “His family is very proud of him. We miss him very much. The last 18 months of his life were marred by such a horrible disease.”

Confront reported in June 2025 that Oxford University had paid out £850,000 relating to three claims it had received regarding diseases from asbestos exposure. We have asked the university for further details on the nature of the three claims, but have not received a response.
According to several lawyers Confront has spoken with, mesothelioma is by far the most common disease involved in compensation claims for asbestos diseases, as mesothelioma is almost always caused by asbestos exposure.
However, lung cancer is potentially the most common asbestos disease in the UK, yet it is rarely included in litigation. This is due to the challenges in identifying asbestos as a culprit in someone’s lung cancer, let alone proving it through litigation.
Withholding information
It took nearly a year to gain access to the asbestos management audits. Confront requested information and documents relating to Oxford University’s asbestos management in August 2024, under the Environmental Information Regulations.
In response, the university only disclosed the number of asbestos-containing materials on campus. In a severely delayed response to an internal review requested by Confront, Oxford provided more details on compensation claims and removal costs, but cited exemptions and withheld the two asbestos management audits. As a result, Confront reported the university to the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO).
The university’s response to the ICO included that disclosure of some information within these audits could lead to anxiety among inhabitants of buildings containing asbestos. The case officer’s report noted that, “The University considers that releasing information about specific buildings could also cause undue alarm and anxiety among building occupants… such distress may negatively impact the mental well-being of those concerned, particularly where the presence of asbestos doesn’t pose an immediate risk but requires careful management.”
The university was seemingly also concerned about intentional tampering with asbestos-containing materials, though none were specifically referenced in the audits. “The University also considers that, if occupants knew where asbestos was located in a building, they might attempt to interfere with the asbestos and so potentially put themselves at physical risk.”
The ICO found the university’s response breached regulations 5(2), 9(2) and 11(4) of the Environmental Information Regulations. Only personal information was deemed worthy of being redacted.
The Oxford branch of the University and College Union (UCU) expressed disappointment at the university’s actions.
Oxford UCU Branch Committee member David Chivall said, “Oxford UCU is extremely concerned that information about the location and management of asbestos in University buildings – including the University’s own assessment that it is in breach of the Control of Asbestos Regulations – has been withheld from staff working in affected buildings.”
“Health and safety issues must be handled with full transparency: disclosure of hazards, risk assessment, communication, and appropriate training are essential.”
Asbestos issue for many universities
Oxford University is far from the only university to withhold or refuse to supply information during our investigation. Our report in January detailed several universities as being unable or unwilling to provide information on their asbestos management. Nevertheless, our reports so far have identified previous or current issues with asbestos management at Imperial College London, the University of Bristol, the University of St Andrews, Newcastle University, and the University of Aberdeen.
Several universities were identified as having received a significant number of compensation claims relating to asbestos exposure, including the University of Manchester (22), Queen’s University Belfast (12), Imperial College London (8), the University of Bath (7), King’s College London (7), and the University of Cambridge (6). Not every claim may have been settled.
The financial cost to universities in managing the legacy of the asbestos industry can be significant. Oxford University estimated it has spent £7,635,722 on asbestos management and removal between 2020 and the start of 2025. Collectively, universities are estimated to spend several tens of millions of pounds every year to manage or remove asbestos on their campuses; a process that will continue for the foreseeable future, given how much asbestos remains across campuses.
The asbestos industry had continued to produce and lobby for the use of its products in universities, schools, and hospitals, even after evidence had emerged that low exposures to asbestos could be fatal. Campaigners and MPs have called on what was one of the UK’s largest asbestos companies, Cape – now owned by Altrad – to make a £10million donation for mesothelioma research. Cape continues to refuse the request.
Correction: the audit was conducted by PWC, not KPMG.